The most valuable LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean minifigures
53 LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean minifigures exist, but only a handful sell for serious money on the secondary market. This ranking shows the top 25 by completed BrickLink sale prices over the last 6 months.
The average Pirates of the Caribbean figure sells for $21.18. The figures below sell for far more. The #1 spot goes to Davy Jones at $143.55. If you sort bulk lots or buy collections, these are the figures worth checking for.
How rare are the most valuable Pirates of the Caribbean minifigures?
Davy Jones is both the most valuable and among the scarcest, and 24 of these top 25 figures appeared in only one set, with the earliest dating to 2011. A figure released in a single set had one production run, so supply never grew. That is the difference between an expensive figure and a rare one.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most expensive LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean minifigure?
Davy Jones (poc031) is the most expensive Pirates of the Caribbean minifigure, selling for an average of $143.55 on BrickLink. In second place is Angelica at $75.29. These prices come from completed sales, not listing prices, so they reflect what buyers pay.
How are BrickLink minifigure prices calculated?
The prices on this page are 6-month rolling averages from completed BrickLink sales. We use averages rather than last-sold prices because single sales can be outliers. Someone might sell a figure cheap to move it fast, or a bidding war might inflate a single sale. The 6-month window smooths this out and gives you a realistic expectation of what you'll get when you list.
How do I know if I have a valuable Pirates of the Caribbean minifigure?
The fastest way is the brick'em scanner. Take a photo of the figure and it returns the ID and current market price. If you prefer manual lookup, check the BrickLink ID printed on the torso or legs (you may need to check the parts against BrickLink's catalog). The figures on this page are the ones worth the effort of identifying and listing individually rather than selling in a bulk lot.
Should I sell valuable minifigures individually or in lots?
Any figure worth more than $10-15 is almost always better sold individually on BrickLink. Buyers searching for specific figures will pay full market price, whereas bulk lot buyers price conservatively since they're taking a risk on what's included. For the figures on this ranking, list individually. The extra time to photograph and list each one pays for itself many times over at these price points.
What are the rarest LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean minifigures?
Davy Jones is both the most valuable and among the scarcest, and 24 of these top 25 figures appeared in only one set, with the earliest dating to 2011. Rarity and price track each other closely in Pirates of the Caribbean, so the figures at the top of this ranking are also the hardest to find. The scarcity signal to check is how many sets a figure was released in: a figure available in only one set had a single production run, which is why it holds value.
Is a rare LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean minifigure always worth more?
Not always. Rarity sets the supply, but demand decides the price. A figure from one obscure set can stay cheap if few collectors want it, while a popular character released in several sets can still sell well. The figures listed here score high on both: limited releases and steady buyer demand.
Explore Pirates of the Caribbean
Browse the complete Pirates of the Caribbean collection, check set prices, or scan your own minifigures to see what they're worth.